Planes, Trains & Automobiles (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES (1987) R 93 Minutes Director: John Hughes Writer: John Hughes Steve Martin, John Candy, Laila Robins
CAST Steve Martin...Neal Page John Candy...Del Griffith Laila Robins...Susan Page Michael McKean...State Trooper Dylan Baker...Owen Edie McClurg...Car Rental Agent Kevin Bacon...Taxi Racer Larry Hankin...Doobie William Windom...Bryant Lyman Ward...John

PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES (1987)

In 1995, my dad took me to a yard sale where I came away with a pristine pair of Reebok basketball shoes, a Chicago Bulls Starter jacket, and, for reasons I can't entirely explain, a four-foot inflatable punching bag advertising PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES. The shoes and jacket were the real prizes, so I doubt my dad paid more than a dollar or two for the inflatable. I punched Steve Martin and John Candy around for a while before relegating them to a corner, where I'd occasionally return to give them another beating. The funny thing is, I hadn't even seen the movie. It would be several more years before I finally watched it, and longer still before I realized that this ridiculous yard-sale afterthought was advertising what would become my favorite movie.

There's nothing like the whole family gathering around the TV at Thanksgiving for a little P-T and A. I've been recommending exactly that for years: first at the end of my DUMB AND DUMBER TO review, when that movie left me wanting a John Hughes experience, and again at the end of my JOHN CANDY: I LIKE ME review. Both times it was a one-line recommendation, which is considerably easier than explaining why a movie means so much to you. PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES is my favorite movie. That isn't necessarily the same as the best movie ever made.

For this review, I watched it twice. The first time I kept pausing, and it turns out a paused frame of John Candy's face is a better lesson in acting than most of the movies I've reviewed. The second time I watched straight through with my parents in the room, mostly to make sure I wasn't looking at it through rose-colored glasses. It still holds up.

Hughes got the idea from a trip of his own. According to the Candy biography, he spent five days trying to get from New York to Chicago for Thanksgiving, and along the way he met a loud, guileless traveling salesman who "knew everything about this kind of situation." Hughes turned those two perspectives into Neal Page, the man who expects a three-hour commute, and Del Griffith, the man who anticipates the unexpected. Neal's whole philosophy fits in a sentence he tosses to a colleague on his way out of the office: "I get in the elevator, I get in the taxi, I get on the plane, then I'm home." Every step is a handoff he assumes will go through. Neal later admits he's spent too much time away from home himself, so experience can't be the whole difference. Del goes with the flow, "like a twig on the shoulders of a mighty stream," and his flow gets him a rental car while Neal's planning gets him keys to one that isn't there. Neither approach works alone. Del's car goes on Neal's Diners Club card, which Del claims turned up in his own wallet, and by the end of that night it has burned. Neal's control survives exactly as long as nothing goes wrong. I walk around the world more like Neal, but when I encounter someone like Del, I'm inclined to meet him halfway. I'll entertain a conversation, even when I'd rather be left alone. That doesn't mean I'm always more patient than Neal, just that I'm better at hiding my impatience.

The film's train stalls out, and the passengers are told to walk a mile and a half to a highway where trucks will take them into Jefferson City. My own worst train ride wasn't nearly so dramatic. I took Amtrak to Vancouver with my sisters for a day trip on a bitterly cold day, and the train kept stopping for reasons nobody explained. What should have taken a couple of hours took five or six, which still left time for dinner and a walk through Stanley Park before heading home. The train was playing THE SANTA CLAUSE 2 on a loop, and I watched it at least three times. On the return trip it was still playing, so I found something else to do. There wasn't a thing I could do about the delays. The only decision left was which window to stare out of.

A modern version of this movie would probably be a lot shorter. There's less face-to-face interaction now, and many of the inconveniences that bring Neal and Del together could be handled on a phone. A stolen credit card can be frozen in seconds, a missing rental sends you searching for another on an app, and the pair would probably take twelve different Ubers home. But technology can't do much about weather or system failures. On November 13, 2026, an FAA communications problem caused the first nationwide ground stop since January 2023. According to the Associated Press, an American Airlines flight from Wichita to Chicago sat on the runway for about an hour before returning to the gate. Passengers were told it was because of "air traffic conditions in Chicago." Back in the movie, Neal's wife, Susan, says, "I don't understand what Wichita has to do with a snowstorm in Chicago." Neal's plane at least made it to Wichita. This one never left.

The first motel confrontation arrives earlier than I remembered. Neal's blowup starts about 23 minutes in, and Del's answer is over by the 26-minute mark, which leaves more than an hour for the film to live with what was said. Neal's lines are also the funniest in the scene, and that's by design. "It's like going on a date with a Chatty Cathy doll" is a joke before it's an insult. So is "Honey, I'd like you to meet Del Griffith. He's got some amusing anecdotes for you. And here's a gun so you can blow your brains out." Hughes lets us laugh, and then lets Del answer. Del doesn't argue that he's good company. He admits he talks too much, adds that he also listens too much, and lands on the line that sums him up: "I like... I like me. My wife likes me. My customers like me 'cause I'm the real article. What you see is what you get."

It hadn't occurred to me how much of Neal's anger has nothing to do with Del. He's already furious about a cab, a flight, and a hotel line, and Del is the one person within reach. A deleted scene at the Page house suggests Neal's troubles extend beyond this trip. Someone says he's been "traveling nonstop for two years" and that "when he is here, his mind is somewhere else." That's a version of Neal the finished film leaves mostly unexplored. The bonus footage also contains a longer version of Del's speech, including "I like people, Neal. People are my business" and "Flaws, fat and boring stories. I'm flesh and blood. I'm a human being." Neal apologizes afterward. I suspect he'd have come to his senses eventually anyway, but the theatrical cut doesn't resolve the argument so neatly. Instead, the next morning finds Del kissing Neal's ear and holding his hand in his sleep. It's played for laughs, but putting that scene immediately after their confrontation feels like a deliberate choice. Moving on to the comedy is a smart move, because if you stay with that scene, it makes you a little sad.

Del almost didn't work. The original screenplay described him as a "slovenly, grotesque slob," and Hughes's son James remembers an airport scene full of sight gags, with Del eating a chili dog and smoking. Editor Paul Hirsch told Vanity Fair that test audiences started to perceive John Candy as taking advantage of Steve Martin, and some of them walked out. The fix was a single exchange. Hirsch restored a few lines at the train station, where Del asks Neal for his address so he can repay him for the ticket. Neal tells him it's a gift, and Hirsch says that one exchange changed the audience's attitude toward Del. The movie remembers it, too. About half an hour later, when Neal accuses him of stealing the credit card, Del says he was going to send it back "with whatever the rental car charge was, plus interest. But you didn't give me your address. What was I supposed to do?" It's a punchline, but it only works because we already know Del asked.

I'd say Candy did the rest. Catherine O'Hara describes him as "completely open" on screen, and says that when Del delivers his "I like me" speech, you want to turn on Neal for having hurt him. That's the test-screening problem in reverse, and it's why the stammer in "I like... I like me" gets me. Del doesn't say it like a man announcing his best quality. It sounds more like a man making sure it's still true. Martin remembers that Candy's longer confession near the end made him cry every time, but the biography says test audiences laughed, and James Hughes recalls Hirsch feeling that the movie had come screeching to a halt. Earlier, restoring a few lines had made Del more sympathetic. Here, cutting most of a beautifully performed confession allowed Neal to discover the truth himself. I think John Hughes made the right decision. Candy didn't need a longer speech to break our hearts, and Neal needed the opportunity to show how much he'd changed. Having watched ONLY THE LONELY before revisiting this, I could see the beginnings of the quieter, more vulnerable performance Candy would give in that film four years later.

Neal tries to end it at 44:19. He frames it as a favor, saying he thinks he's the one holding Del up. Del insists that isn't true, and Neal drops the pretense: "we'll get to where we're going a lot faster if we were alone." Del says, "OK. I see," and then there are ten seconds without a line of dialogue. About six minutes after Neal walks off, Del is back, saying he'd had a feeling "somehow, someday, our paths would cross again." The film never argues that Neal is wrong to be worn out by Del. Del is exhausting, and the movie lets us feel it. What it keeps asking is what that exhaustion is worth. I think of the two men as having separate missions. Neal's is to get home, and he says so out loud, repeatedly. Del's is to forget, for a while, that he's lonely, and he never says so, which is probably why Neal can't see it. From Neal's side of the table, Del is a delay. From Del's, Neal is a chance not to be alone.

The motel scene toward the end, where they're drinking and eating Doritos, might be one of my three favorite scenes in the movie, and it works because neither mission has anywhere left to go. The car has burned, and nothing can move until morning. Del is outside in the cold. Neal asks himself what he did to get hooked up with this guy, then opens the door anyway: "You're going to freeze to death out there." Nothing in the plot requires it. In their first motel room, nearly everything Del did irritated Neal. Here, with their circumstances even worse, they actually enjoy each other's company. They work their way through miniature bottles of liquor, agree it's probably a bad combination, then toast their wives, which hits differently on a second viewing, but I'll come back to that. Neal says he'll look back on all of this and laugh someday, then admits he's laughing already. They find chips in the bed, and one of them wonders why he feels like he's at summer camp. Neal finally likes Del, and the movie doesn't stop to say so. I don't think this film is only about friendship. It's about discovering the value of someone you had no desire to know. Circumstances keep throwing Neal and Del together, but eventually Neal chooses to go back.

I said I'd come back to the toast. The film plants Marie in plain sight. About thirteen minutes in, Del tells Neal he has a motto: "Like your work. Love your wife." During the "I like me" speech, he says, "My wife likes me." Alone in the cold outside the motel, he says, "Well, Marie, once again, my dear, you were as right as rain." When Neal tells him that at least he has "a woman you love to grow old with," Del answers, "Love is not a big enough word for how I feel about my wife," and they drink to the wives. None of it is a lie, exactly. Del talks about Marie in the present tense because that's where his feelings are. The closest he comes to telling Neal the truth is at 43:38, when he says, "I haven't been home in years," and then takes it back as "a figure of speech." At the end of the trip, Neal says, "Say hello to Marie for me. I feel like I know her," and Del's answer is "Yeah." When the truth finally lands, the film replays the clues for Neal: "My wife likes me." "You've got a woman you love to grow old with, right?" "I haven't been home in years." Of those three lines, the middle one is Neal's own, played back to him. The last echoes three times.

What the film doesn't say, I can't stop thinking about. It tells us that Marie has been dead for eight years, and it spends two sentences on it: "I don't have a home. Marie's been dead for eight years." The longer version, the biography says, covered her illness and why Del sold the house, and I don't need it. Everything else is my guess. Del spent his working life on the road, so I suspect he was gone a lot. I sometimes wonder whether a little time apart was actually good for their marriage. The film never says either way. What it does give me is Del telling Neal, "I don't want to argue, all right? Let's not fight," in a tone that doesn't sound improvised. It sounds like something he's said before, and I'd love to know who he said it to. I'm equally curious about his childhood, and the finished film gives me nothing. The bonus footage offers a single line, "My father was a salesman," attached to a tip for tired feet, and I'll take it. The image I keep is a small one. Moments after Del tells Neal he's one lucky guy and Neal says, "I know," Neal hugs his wife, and Del stands off to the side, awkwardly gripping his hat. For a man who never stops talking, he has nothing to say.

I think this is a movie that wants other people in the room, which seems right for a story about being stuck with someone. Twelve or fourteen years ago, I was watching it at a friend's house, with only the two of us there. I'd been curating the evening like James Lipton hosting a film festival, and the main feature had been SPACE JAM, all the way through. It was getting late, and about half an hour into PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES, my friend said he had to go to bed. "Finish the movie if you want, but lock the door on your way out." We'd been friends since middle school, so I took him at his word and stayed. I could have put this movie on first. Instead, I became the houseguest who stays after the host has gone to bed, which makes me Del Griffith, minus the shower curtain rings.

The inflatable I punched around in 1995 had a bit of weight at the bottom, so it popped back up every time. I didn't know it was the most accurate piece of merchandise ever made for this movie. Neal ditches Del, and later, when Del asks, "Are you mad at me?" Neal slugs him in the gut. But Del keeps popping back up, and by the end Neal is the one who goes back for him. The last thing the film gives us is Candy's smile, and you could put it in an art gallery.

John Candy as Del Griffith, smiling

Final Verdict: 99 out of 100


Son in Law (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


SON IN LAW (1993) PG-13 95 Minutes Director: Steve Rash Writers: Fax Bahr, Adam Small, Shawn Schepps Pauly Shore, Carla Gugino, Lane Smith
CAST Pauly Shore...Crawl Carla Gugino...Rebecca Warner Lane Smith...Walter Warner Cindy Pickett...Connie Warner Mason Adams...Walter Warner Sr. Patrick Renna...Zack Warner Dennis Burkley...Theo Dan Gauthier...Travis Tiffani-Amber Thiessen...Tracy Ria Pavia...Carol

I went to college for about five years. It was a special school, I believe it was called community college. But I got my share of the four-year college experience, too. Sometimes I'd visit friends of friends up in Bellingham. Don't get me wrong, I think education is a valuable thing, but the way the college types socialized wasn't really for me.

SON IN LAW opens at a high school graduation in South Dakota, where the principal tells the seniors of Lincoln High that they started out as caterpillars in a cocoon of stability, that he can almost hear their cocoons opening, and that he sees monarch butterflies. Valedictorian Rebecca Warner follows with a speech about change. It happens "whether we want it or not," she says, before asking her classmates if they're ready for it. "I think so," she answers herself. Her classmates respond with a raspberry and a snore. It's a parade of clichés and platitudes, and I've heard better speeches, even from teenagers. Rebecca has three months to find out whether she meant any of it. That night, her father, Walter, tries to prepare her for California. "The boys are different than they are here," he says, and after a few false starts, "the lifestyle's a lot faster." She asks if he's trying to tell her not to have sex. After a two-day drive, the Warners arrive at the dorm, where Walter goes looking for a screwdriver to open Rebecca's trunk. The guy he finds says he's all out of vodka, asks whether Walter's daughter is hot, and promises to keep "a special eye on her." Then he introduces himself as Crawl, the resident advisor. Walter tells Connie he won't have Rebecca living across the hall from "that thing." Rebecca told her classmates she was ready for change. Her father, it turns out, is not.

My first idea of what a resident advisor was came from SAVED BY THE BELL: THE COLLEGE YEARS, where the guy running the dorm looked way too old to be a student. Upon further investigation, he was a resident director, a staff position, so the show had an excuse. Crawl doesn't. When Rebecca announces she's leaving school, he asks for five minutes and shows her a photo of himself freshman year, a nerd named Fred. "I tossed the spectacles," he says. "Grew the do, guzzled some brew." She asks how long he's been there. Six years, he says, and he's "majored in almost everything." He doesn't know what he wants to be yet, but right now he's having fun. Then, unexpectedly, he makes a good point: how can she try anything new if she hasn't left campus? Within a few minutes she's been fitted with what Crawl calls "weasel wear" and has a tattoo. It's a butterfly, which is how the principal's speech pays off. The Weasel is Pauly Shore's stage persona, and the movie doesn't bother hiding it. Crawl's own background sounds like a tall tale. His mother is a pit boss in Las Vegas on her fourth marriage, to a man who sells catheters and bedpans to hospitals. What I didn't know when I first saw the movie was that Shore's actual upbringing was even stranger. His parents, Sammy and Mitzi Shore, co-founded The Comedy Store. Shore has said he never planned to attend college, which makes him an odd choice to play a student who won't leave.

Rebecca comes home for Thanksgiving with Crawl, whom she introduces as a neighbor who had nowhere else to go. Travis is waiting for her. About 35 minutes in, I could already tell I didn't like him. What kind of loser wears a letterman's jacket after graduating high school? The movie explains the problem in its opening, when Rebecca lays out the plan: she'll go to school, he'll work at the co-op, and they'll see each other every vacation until she's done. Travis isn't pursuing his own life. He's waiting for hers to finish. His first attempt at a proposal ends when Rebecca claims to be dizzy, and she tells Crawl she's too young to settle down but doesn't want to hurt him. So Travis tries again that night, in front of a room full of guests, announcing that he and Rebecca have been "courting for almost five years." She graduated high school three months ago, so that puts the start of their courtship somewhere around seventh grade. When he finally asks, Rebecca tells Crawl to do something. Crawl stands up and says Travis is "too late," because a couple of weeks ago at school he asked Rebecca to marry him, and she said yes. She didn't want to hurt Travis, so she had Crawl tell the whole room he'd been replaced.

One thing you can say about Crawl is that he has an open mind. He kisses the ground when he arrives, greets the fields like a surf break ("Rippin' the fields! Gettin' barreled! Pipeline!"), and tells the Warners he's never been anywhere so pure. After one morning of farming, he has destroyed a fence, lost half the chickens, and messed up the tractor, which Walter puts at close to $1,000. Walter reminds him that he doesn't have a job. "Well, yes, I do," Crawl says. "I'm a farmer." It's almost a movie version of CLARKSON'S FARM, with Theo as the farmhand who knows how the morning will go. Underneath all its stupidity, YOU, ME AND DUPREE is about keeping your essence, and SON IN LAW works much the same way. Crawl doesn't have to become somebody else to win over the Warners. They learn to appreciate him as he is. He gives Connie the same five-minute pitch he gave Rebecca, and that night he's telling her daughter that her parents are getting busy. You expect the movie to turn into WHAT ABOUT BOB, where the houseguest charms the family and the host comes apart. Walter starts down that road. He tells Crawl he stinks "to high heaven" and picks a fight with his whole family at the table, and Crawl announces he's leaving. Then Walter says "nobody's goin' anywhere," the family asks Crawl to stay, and the movie never goes there again.

Lane Smith is the perfect dad for this movie. He played the district attorney in MY COUSIN VINNY, and later that year he started as Perry White on LOIS & CLARK, so he knows how to play an exasperated man in charge of people who won't listen. Walter's father, played by Mason Adams, had been the managing editor on LOU GRANT, which means this farm family has more newsroom experience than you'd expect. Walter can barely remember Crawl's name. He tries "Crotch" and "Cramp" before he asks what kind of name that is anyway. On the morning of the fishing trip, Zack is playing a fishing game on his Game Boy. Walter offers to take him along, and Zack says, "I don't feel like it." So Crawl goes instead, and Walter's father comes too. Walter Sr. spends the trip picking at his son's sidearm casting and complaining that every time he tries to help, Walter turns on him "like a viper in the grass." Crawl tells Walter he feels sorry for him, then adds that he treats Zack the same way, and that the computer games matter more to Zack than Walter realizes. "Who asked you?" Walter says. A moment later his father collapses, and Crawl attempts CPR, including mouth-to-mouth. "If it's between my dyin' or him kissin' me," Walter Sr. says, "I'd rather die." Adams doesn't get many lines, but they all land. Crawl's observation about Walter and Zack is perhaps the sharpest in the movie, and he makes it while holding his fishing rod upside down.

Crawl is a little naive, but he should see Travis coming from a mile away. The night after Crawl tells a room full of guests that Travis has been replaced, Travis apologizes and offers to throw him a bachelor party. "I'd really like that a lot, Travis," Crawl says, and he hugs him. "What a splendid person." Then Travis asks Tracy for a favor, and she tells him she'll wait up for him. She's clearly into Travis, but he's still trying to get Rebecca back, and he has no objection to using Tracy to do it. The party is at a bar where everybody is drinking, although most of these people seem barely out of high school. Rebecca had a beer in front of her at the mud-wrestling bar, too. The movie doesn't explain, so I'll assume fake IDs were a thing. The next morning, Crawl wakes up in a barn with Tracy, remembering only karaoke, and Rebecca walks in on them and calls off the wedding. The truth surfaces at Thanksgiving dinner, when Tracy produces a bottle of pills and notes that someone awfully big must have been driving her car. Theo admits he and Travis put the two of them in the barn, and he calls it a joke. I was suspicious of Travis the whole time, but I expected more from Theo. Walter fires him, Crawl punches Travis, and Connie invites Tracy to stay for dinner. A plot to drug two people and leave them in a barn gets treated as a prank that went too far, and everyone moves on with their lives. Even a split-second shot of Travis behind bars would have helped.

Travis from Son in Law sitting behind bars
This is how the movie should've ended.

Because the story is set on a farm, you mostly forget what year it is until Zack pulls out his Game Boy, and that's not such a bad thing. Other reminders include the Spin Doctors and roller blades. It's funny that I brought up SAVED BY THE BELL: THE COLLEGE YEARS earlier, because Tiffani-Amber Thiessen is in this. It was her film debut, and she was still playing Kelly Kapowski on TV. Between her, Patrick Renna, and Pauly Shore, the cast is practically a 1993 time capsule. Renna played Ham in THE SANDLOT that same year. The movie made $36.4 million in the U.S. on an $8 million budget. Disney had fought New Line to get Shore for it, and MTV promoted it with a contest to marry him in Las Vegas that drew more than 25,000 entries, although no marriage certificates were signed. That seems about right for a movie built on a fake engagement.

Nobody says the title until the last scene. At Thanksgiving dinner, Walter asks his "future son-in-law" to carve the turkey, and Rebecca stops him to explain that she and Crawl were never sure about the wedding date, so they're putting things on hold. "No use rushing into these things," Walter says, and dinner starts with his invitation to "munch on some grindage." It's a nice ending for a family that spent most of the movie arguing, and it works because Lane Smith and Mason Adams bring such warmth to the material, while Pauly Shore never stops being Crawl. The movie closes on a freeze-frame of the happy family, with "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" playing, as though nothing particularly troubling has happened. For all its stupidity, SON IN LAW is still mostly a sweet comedy.

Final Verdict: 67 out of 100


Dutch (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


DUTCH (1991) PG-13 107 Minutes Director: Peter Faiman Writer: John Hughes Ed O'Neill, Ethan Randall, JoBeth Williams
CAST Ed O'Neill...Dutch Dooley Ethan Randall...Doyle Standish JoBeth Williams...Natalie Standish Christopher McDonald...Reed Standish Ari Meyers...Brock E.G. Daily...Hailey L. Scott Caldwell...Homeless Woman Kathleen Freeman...Gritzi Mickey Jones...Truck Driver

DUTCH (1991)

DUTCH is one of those movies that was on basic cable all the time in the '90s and early 2000s. I was never completely enamored with the film. When it was on, I'd maybe watch a few comedic scenes before changing the channel. There was something missing. Nothing major, nothing I could easily identify, but enough to keep me from becoming particularly attached to it. I still feel that way, although having watched it again, I find there's considerably more to appreciate than I previously realized. In fact, I think DUTCH is worth watching once or twice…all the way through, in spite of its flaws.

The setup is simple. At a country-club Thanksgiving party, Natalie Standish runs into her ex-husband Reed, who tells her he has to leave for London in the morning. He hasn't told their son Doyle, who is away at a boarding school in Georgia and expecting to spend the holiday with his father. Natalie calls to break the news, and Doyle accuses her of trying to buy his approval of her new boyfriend. Dutch has a better idea. "There's no better way for two guys to get to know each other than to spend a couple of days in a car," he says, and when Natalie warns him that Doyle doesn't want to know him, he brushes it off. "I've handled some pretty tough birds in my time." When the smoke cleared, he says, he almost always ended up with a new friend.

A working-class man fetching a kid from a fancy school reminded me of OVER THE TOP, where Sylvester Stallone picks his estranged son up from military school and tries to make up for lost time in one long drive. DUTCH takes the same trip and swaps the father for a stand-in, a man with no claim on the boy and every reason to want one.

Class is the movie's first argument, and it announces itself at the party. Natalie tells the women that Reed got her pregnant when she was a barhop at the country club, married her to avoid scandal, and then beat her in court. Asked to point out her new boyfriend when he arrives, she says they'll know him when they see him. Dutch confirms it by telling the room he doesn't care for caviar, since he makes it a rule never to eat anything a fish deposits in a riverbed. Reed is played by Christopher McDonald, who is playing a villain again, and the mustache is a nice touch. When Natalie asks whether he would ever play fair, he answers, "I wouldn't dare lose." That one line covers the whole marriage.

In the car, Doyle takes over the class argument. He lists what gives Dutch away: cheap shoes, a ridiculous hairstyle, a crude vocabulary, and his mother's taste in men. Asked whether working class is bad, Doyle allows that a solid economy needs hand workers, and Dutch tells him he used to drive a cement truck, that his father was a bricklayer, and that his mother worked in a hotel laundry. "You must be very proud," Doyle says. "I am," Dutch answers. But the movie takes care to show that Dutch isn't poor. He says he makes a pretty good living, more than Reed gives Natalie, and that his money doesn't count in Doyle's neighborhood "because I worked for it." Later he admits he had $200 in his wallet when he told Doyle they had $20, suggesting that at least some of their hardship has been self-imposed. When Doyle suggests a telephone, Dutch calls his refusal "old-fashioned, pigheaded, working-class" masculine pride. He isn't proving he can rough it. He's proving he doesn't have to ask anyone for help.

I shudder to think what Doyle would have become without Dutch. He looks like a future Wall Street sociopath, a kid who answers "What makes you think you're so superior?" with "I don't have to think." He threatens to have Teddy written up and predicts a career at Burger King for him. But beneath all that arrogance is a boy who spends most of the movie miserable, and not only because Dutch is there. Teddy's reply, "At least I have a father," is the one insult in that scene he leaves unanswered.

When his mother tells him his father is going to Europe, there's a long silence on the line before he goes after her instead, accusing her of wanting his approval of her new boyfriend. Teddy then comes back to invite him to Thanksgiving at his own parents' house, the same Teddy Doyle mocked for being enrolled because his father is an employee, and Doyle says he couldn't handle that much fun. Later he demands his father's London number from a woman on the phone, insisting he has a letter promising his father would pick him up. Dutch's plan, as Doyle describes it to Brock, is to "drag me around until I break," and his insistence that he doesn't break sounds like a kid with practice. Dutch may not be changing Doyle so much as giving him room to show what was already there.

Dutch is right about one thing: there's no better way for two guys to get to know each other than a couple of days in a car. I've taken plenty of eight- or ten-hour day trips with a friend who didn't have a driver's license, so I did all the driving. With enough tiredness, you eventually become incapable of being anything other than yourself. If the other person still likes you, you've probably got a friend for life. I also took a trip to Northern California with another friend. We were both pretty quiet, and spending hours in a car didn't suddenly make us more talkative. He couldn't stand my leisurely driving, either; by the time we reached Oregon, he'd taken the wheel. But we spent plenty of weekends watching football together, and I don't think either of us needed much conversation to enjoy the other's company. Spending that much time together doesn't necessarily make two people closer. Sometimes it just shows you how different they are, and that tells you little about how close they already were.

Doyle's guard begins to slip during the drive. Dutch starts out in control, with Doyle gagged in the back seat while he drives the back roads and offers an apology of sorts. "I'm not 100% sure those undershorts I jammed in your mouth to shut you up were clean or not," he says. The first real crack comes at the fireworks store, which is based on a real one. According to the AFI Catalog, the producers found a big one in Kimball, Tennessee, while driving the route from Atlanta to Chicago, and Hughes wrote it into the script.

On the second viewing I noticed something smaller, right before Dutch goes in. Doyle starts to get out of the car to follow him, then changes his mind. When Dutch returns, Doyle points out that fireworks are illegal in Illinois, and Dutch says this is Tennessee, so it doesn't matter. Dutch rattles off his haul: M-80s, dragon tongues, Jersey stinkers, and Bombay bugles, along with a bag of pretzels and a deck of racy playing cards. The store shares its lot with a gas station, which Dutch is quick to say is no place to set anything off. Soon Doyle is calling him "a great big, demented child," and Dutch is giggling.

A few other bits worked for me. I missed what might be the best gag of the trip on my first viewing: Dutch gets squirted in the mouth with moisturizer while he sleeps in the front seat, and afterward he keeps licking his lips like he can't quite place the taste. Mickey Jones has a small role as a truck driver, and I was glad to see him, since I know him from his Bob Dylan days and HOME IMPROVEMENT. And those Pan Am bags really were indestructible. I probably still have one in a closet somewhere, picked up at a yard sale.

The turning point comes after Brock and Hailey, the call girls who give the boys a ride to Hammond, drive off with Dutch's wallet, luggage, and last cigar. Doyle had spent the ride talking to Brock, the first person he opens up to. When she tells him maybe he should stop knocking his mom and try to make things work with her, he says that isn't going to happen, then adds, "But I really like talking to you." Dutch sits down at the gas station and tells Doyle to call his mother and give her the message that "the Dutchboy's calling it quits." Doyle objects that it's sick to cut his mom loose because Dutch can't get along with him. "I blew it. I'm sorry. I'm also out of ideas," Dutch says, and I still can't tell whether he means it or is bluffing. Doyle goes to a phone and calls his father instead. A woman whispers that Mr. Standish is sleeping, and Reed asks who it was. "Some kid," she says. When Doyle comes back, he's the one insisting they can make it home. Once Dutch announces he's calling Natalie, Doyle stops him. "It would really mean a lot to me to not have to call my mother for help." It's Dutch's own male-pride argument coming out of Doyle's mouth, and it's the first time he's on Dutch's side.

The shelter scene is one of the better parts of the movie. After they're told to leave a place where Dutch hoped Doyle could wash the cut on his head, a couple asks Dutch, "The boy's your son?" "That's right," Dutch says, and they send the pair to a center for displaced families. At night Dutch asks Doyle to switch cots because his own won't hold him. "How do you know it'll hold me?" Doyle asks. "Because I'm 15,000 cheeseburgers ahead of you in life."

Then a woman tells Doyle that her husband lost his job in June when an auto-parts company went broke, and that they've been living out of the back of their car. The kid who spent the first half of the movie sneering at Dutch's shoes and hairstyle says, "That's kind of hard." When she asks, "You and your daddy?" there's a long pause before he answers, "Yeah." She asks if he has a mother, if she's in Chicago, if he'd like to be with her right now. "Yes," he says, and after a moment, "Yeah, I would." Dutch, within earshot, smiles. It's where Doyle finally begins peeling away that layer of thinking he's better than everyone else. Afterward Dutch tells him he called Natalie and said they were at the Holiday Inn so she wouldn't worry, and asks if that's okay. "No, that's okay," Doyle says. The shelter has become a secret the two of them share.

The ending starts well and then loses its nerve. Reed shows up at Natalie's house claiming he canceled an overseas trip to spend the holiday with Doyle, and Doyle calls him on it: "No, you didn't. I called your house, and a lady answered. You lied to me." Reed makes him choose. "Are you coming with me or are you staying here? Your decision is final." Doyle answers, "I'm staying here, Dad." Meanwhile, there's something different about Dutch in this scene. He keeps his hat on indoors, and with the hat framing his face, all you notice are his eyes. I wonder if that was a deliberate choice by the filmmakers, since he could have taken it off right away.

Dutch's confrontation with Reed afterward is the other part that works, because it feels like something the character would really do. Reed has told Natalie he wants her out by Monday. Dutch gets him up to six months, makes him promise to be more respectful, and tells him to work on being a nice guy with his son because he still loves him. "I'm never gonna be his father," Dutch says. "That's your job. You'd better learn to do it." Earlier at the shelter, Doyle told a stranger that Dutch was his father. Now Dutch is telling the boy's actual father that he has a responsibility no one else can fulfill. It's a surprisingly generous thing to say to a man he despises.

Then dinner starts and it goes off the rails. Dutch sends Doyle for his coat, saying he has something in it for his mother, and fires an air pistol while the table laughs. I know they promised that moment. Dutch threatens it in their first fight, and in the shelter Doyle asks, "You still gonna shoot me in the ass?" "Yes." But the payoff could have come anywhere else in the film. A softer joke would have worked better here.

By the end I was thinking DUTCH mostly needed better editing. I know that isn't literally true. The July 1990 draft screenplay already ends with Dutch pulling an air pistol from behind his back at the dinner table. A softer joke would have required more than a simple cut. But the building blocks for a better movie are all there: the class argument in the car, the misery behind Doyle's sneer, the shelter, Dutch facing down Reed. Some of those repairs wouldn't have taken much. It's hard to say how much of the blame belongs to Hughes and how much to Peter Faiman, a director I'd never heard of who turns out to have made CROCODILE DUNDEE. The gag was on Hughes's page, and it survived into Faiman's finished film. Hughes wrote and directed CURLY SUE three months later, and between the two I'd say he lost a step.

That might also explain why DUTCH never stuck with me on basic cable. The scenes I used to catch before changing the channel were the comedic ones, and the best of the movie is in the parts you only see if you stay.

Final Verdict: 72 out of 100


Something Wicked this Way Comes (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES (1983) PG 95 Minutes Director: Jack Clayton Writer: Ray Bradbury Jason Robards, Jonathan Pryce, Diane Ladd CAST Jason Robards...Charles Halloway Jonathan Pryce...Mr. Dark Diane Ladd...Mrs. Nightshade Vidal Peterson...Will Halloway Shawn Carson...Jim Nightshade Royal Dano...Tom Fury Pam Grier...Dust Witch Mary Grace Canfield...Miss Foley Bruce M. Fischer...Mr. Cooger Richard Davalos...Mr. Crosetti Jake Dengel...Mr. Tetley James Stacy...Ed the Bartender Ellen Geer...Mrs. Halloway Jack Dodson...Dr. Douglas Brendan Klinger...Young Mr. Cooger Arthur Hill...Adult Will Halloway (Narrator)
The freaks come out at night.

— Whodini, "Freaks Come Out at Night" (1984)
SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES (1983)

A few months ago, while reviewing LITTLE BIG LEAGUE, I remember thinking it was a pretty good movie, though one that made the regrettable decision to kill off Jason Robards far too early. He plays the owner of the Minnesota Twins, then dies before we have much chance to get attached to him. With Halloween approaching, I happened upon SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES, a movie in which Robards has the good sense to stick around. And is it any good? Well, you'll have to stick around for the rest of the review to find out. For now, I'll just say it isn't terrible.

Charles Halloway is convinced he's a failure as a father, and the first sixteen minutes establish it. Doc tells him at the bar to remember his heart, one drink and one cigar. At home, he tells his wife that Will makes him feel so darn old, that a man should be able to play baseball with his son. She answers, "Baseball is not necessary, not with a heart like yours." The real confession comes the next evening, when he finally tells Will about a picnic on the Indigo River. A current swept four-year-old Will into the middle of the water, and Charles stood on the bank, helpless, because his own father never thought it was right to teach boys to swim. The man who dove in without taking his boots off was Jim's father. Robards plays all of it weary and apologetic, and he never asks us to feel sorry for him. In the novel, Halloway is the library's janitor. The movie promotes him to librarian, making Dark's jab about "living only through other men's lives" more literal. Then the boys explain why they've been hiding, and Charles says he believes them. Jim objects that they aren't grownups. "That's why I believe you," Charles says. It reminded me of THE SIMPSONS episode "Lisa the Iconoclast," where Homer is the only person in Springfield who takes his daughter's side. Homer's way of backing her up involves digging up a corpse. Charles reads the boys an entry from his father's diary. He's a better dad than he thinks, and the movie has the proof ready. When Dark traps him in front of a mirror and tells him his son hates him, Will answers by shouting that he loves him. Charles shatters the glass.

The carnival works like THE MONKEY'S PAW, except nobody has to find it in a drawer. Every wish gets granted, and the bill comes with it. The movie makes sure we like Ed the bartender before it takes him. He has one arm and one leg, he swings the hammer anyway, and when the bell dings, Will and Jim hug him. It's a short, sweet moment, and then his prize arrives, a free pass to the mirror maze. Ed walks in, sees a reflection with both legs, and we hear him wishing he could run, throw, and tackle again. The next time we see his bar, it's empty. "First time in 20 years," Doc says. Miss Foley, who folks say was once the most beautiful woman in town, comes out of the same maze dazed, talking about how bright and beautiful it was. Dark later calls her a "blind girl." The diary entry Charles reads in the library supplies the rule. A lame servant girl asked the fortuneteller how she might run. "Her leg mended, and then she ran mad." "It seems they destroy people by granting their dearest wishes." Dark never has to invent anyone's unhappiness. He describes his diet in that same library, "funerals, bad marriages, lost loves, lonely beds," and Green Town had plenty of all four. The carnival offers to fix it as a favor, free of charge, and supplies the mirror.

This is where I part ways with the story. Dark's pitch to Charles is a countdown that starts at 30 and gives up at 52 with a "Your loss!" The movie takes place in the 1930s, when a man in his fifties might have felt older than he would today, but I still have trouble accepting fifty-four as an age worth mourning. If I woke up tomorrow twenty years old, I don't think my friends and family would stop caring about me. I'd still be the same person inside, with a couple of extra decades to get to the things I haven't. Dating would be trickier, since I'd have little in common with people my age, but old souls already deal with that. The people who really need this story's warning are Uncle Rico in NAPOLEON DYNAMITE and Al Bundy in MARRIED... WITH CHILDREN, men who would get their youth back and spend it reliving the fourth quarter coach never let one of them play and the four touchdowns the other scored once. No carousel fixes that. Dark's offer to Charles is smarter than that, though. He counts up through "You might still learn to swim" and "a year when you could run up the stairs without panting for breath," which are Charles's own regrets, not a generic wish for youth. Wanting more time to live and being unable to enjoy the life you're in are two different problems. Dark pretends he can solve the first because he knows Charles suffers from the second.

Jim Nightshade is the boy with the most to lose, and the movie shows us why before the carnival arrives. He tells anyone who will listen that his father is in Africa and coming home with a parrot and a shrunken head, and Will points out that Jim's father never writes. Things aren't much better at home. Mrs. Nightshade tells him to find something in the icebox because "Mother's just all tired out." Later he asks her whether he looks like his father. "Too like," she says, and adds that the day he leaves home, her Harry will be dead forever. A mother who can't look at her son without seeing her husband gives him one more reason to want out, and Jim wants out. He's the one who keeps threatening to remember things "when I'm older, darn it," and the one Will accuses of planning to ride the carousel the other way. Compare Will's mother, who marches him upstairs for sneaking out and calls Jim a bad influence. It isn't kind to Jim, but it's the sound of someone paying attention. Dark hears the difference. Calling to the boys in the library, he asks Jim how he'd like to be grown up, not looked down at, not told to run away and play. Then he says, "I'm the father you've been waiting for." Jim has spent the movie waiting on a letter from Africa. Dark shows up in person, which is more than his real father has managed.

The 1980s were good at movies that were creepy without being scary, the kind that ruin one night's sleep and then get watched again the following October. SILVER BULLET is another example, and SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES belongs in the same company. A lot of the charm is in the casting. Jonathan Pryce plays Mr. Dark like a courteous showman, introducing himself with "My name is Mr. Dark. I advise you to respect it," and later explaining that his people butter "plain bread with delicious pain." Pam Grier, who made her name in COFFY and FOXY BROWN, says little as the Dust Witch and is still the most frightening person in any scene she enters. Royal Dano gets some of Bradbury's most colorful dialogue as Tom Fury, the lightning-rod salesman, a man who wants to know what color lightning is and where the thunder goes when it dies. "Did I take the name? No, sir. The name took me." When I read the novel, I figured this would be tough to pull off today, even with modern CGI and expert practical effects. The movie doesn't pull it off entirely. Green Town was built on the Disney Studios backlot, and it looks like exactly that, a storybook street constructed for the occasion. The supernatural events have the handmade look of something put together with a lot of fog and whatever tricks the filmmakers could devise. That's part of why it works. A carnival that arrives in the middle of the night on a train nobody is sure they heard doesn't need to look real. It needs to look like a story somebody told you.

The movie's rough edges make more sense once you know how it got made. Bradbury first wrote a screenplay in 1958 for Gene Kelly, and it took until 1981 and Disney to get it shot. Bradbury and director Jack Clayton eventually fell out over an uncredited rewrite by John Mortimer. The draft I read is dated August 1981 and still has pages revised on September 30, two days after cameras started rolling. Then the test screenings went badly. Disney effectively took the film out of Clayton's hands, reportedly spent another $5 million overhauling it, and brought Bradbury back for a new opening narration and a new ending. Georges Delerue's score was dropped for being too sinister, and James Horner wrote a replacement on short notice. The film planned for Christmas 1982 finally opened on April 29, 1983, which is a strange time of year for a movie about October. The reshoots came long enough after the original shoot that the boys had visibly grown. In a couple of scenes, Will seems about a foot taller. It's almost the MADTV FULL HOUSE reunion sketch, where the Olsen twins, who split the role of Michelle, can no longer pass for the same girl because Nicole Sullivan plays a considerably heavier Mary-Kate. This is a movie about a carousel that rewinds people's ages, and it can't keep its own boys the same age from one scene to the next.

From Will shouting "I love you" at the mirror to the final "Tie!," my subtitle file clocks about six minutes, and a lot happens in them. Jim climbs onto the carousel beside Dark, lightning hits, Dark withers into a husk, the carnival tears itself apart, and a man with a bad heart saves a boy by acting like an idiot. That last part is the best of it, and it's faithful. Charles snaps Will out of his tears, tells him the night people love them, and dances around announcing that he's the great whooping crane, which is nearly line for line what the novel does. Fighting evil with laughter and love is a nice idea, and the movie sells it. What it skips is the novel's other half. In the book, Dark isn't killed by lightning. He has ridden the carousel backward into a lost nine-year-old boy, and Charles recognizes him, holds him close, and starves him with kindness, on the theory that evil has only the power we give it. Afterward, Will asks whether they'll ever come back. "No. And yes," Charles says. "Maybe they're already here." The boys look around and see nobody but themselves. Then all three, including Charles, briefly consider taking another ride on the carousel. The movie replaces that conversation with a narrator telling us that "being old was all right now" for his father, and a footrace that ends in a tie. It's sweet, but the novel leaves all three characters vulnerable to temptation, and the movie lets us go home reassured. The carnival is gone, and everything it fed on is still in town. The movie doesn't need a longer climax so much as a couple more minutes to consider what happens after it.

So, is it any good? I said at the start that it isn't terrible, and I'm willing to go a little further than that. It's uneven, the ending is rushed, and you can see the effects of Disney's attempts to make it more accessible. But Robards is the real thing, the atmosphere holds up, and the ideas under the carnival are better than the film has time to develop. Dark makes his living on dissatisfaction. He finds what someone is missing and sells it back as a favor, always in the politest terms: "Excuse me, gentlemen, I am a stranger in this town." He merely wishes, he says, to give the boys "the valuable rewards that they so richly deserve." Charles has no such manners. He sings badly, dances worse, and gives up his dignity to save a boy who isn't even his. What Dark sells has a price, and what Charles gives away doesn't. Bradbury called the finished film "not a great film, no, but a decently nice one," and I like that he reached for the word nice. Dark has the better manners. Charles has the better heart, bad as it is.

Final Verdict: 77 out of 100

Sidenote: What's Halloween without a little Salem Saberhagen?

Salem Saberhagen

Norm: The Tale of Norm Macdonald

by Edward Dunn


NORM: THE TALE OF NORM MACDONALD (2026) R 126 Minutes Director: Judd Apatow Norm Macdonald, Larry King, Andy Dick
You think you know... but you have no idea.

— MTV's DIARY
NORM: THE TALE OF NORM MACDONALD (2026)

I don't like many Canadians. Just John Candy, Jason Priestley, and Norm Macdonald.

Back in 2013 and 2014, I had something to look forward to on my Monday evening Domino's shifts: a new episode of NORM MACDONALD LIVE. The show wasn't particularly reliable. Some Mondays there would be a new episode waiting for me, and others there would be nothing, a disappointment that could put me in a lousy mood for the rest of the week. When an episode did appear, I did the impossible, some might even describe it as completely reckless. I watched a video podcast, with my phone in my lap, while delivering pizza.

I had a one-sided relationship with a stand-up comic. I consumed every scrap of Norm content I could find. I thought I knew everything about him. But how well do you really know someone who jokingly lies about the basic facts of his own life?

Within the first minute of NORM: THE TALE OF NORM MACDONALD, a caller from Harrison, Arkansas gets on the air with Norm and admits that a couple nights ago, at 5:30 in the morning, he was laughing at Norm clips on YouTube. Comedian Matt McCusker describes the hole you can fall into, and Judd Apatow drops us straight into it. For most of the runtime we're sitting at a desktop computer while clips, articles, and social media posts pile up, a keyboard clacking between them. Apatow put out a call for fans' photos and videos while making the film, so the frame isn't only a conceit. It's also close to how I consumed Norm myself, and I'm still not sure what to make of that. Scrolling doesn't ask much of the person doing it, and for long stretches Apatow seems content to let the clips do the work.

About eight minutes in, Larry King asks Norm whether BASED ON A TRUE STORY, which the cover calls a memoir, is really a novel. "This is a novel, yeah, not a memoir," Norm says. Asked whether to believe any of it, he answers, "It's not facts, but it's truth." The copyright page is no more reassuring. It says the stories begin with the author's recollection of events, which is — by his own admission — spotty, and that several names and identifying details have been changed. Apatow keeps that exchange in, then cuts straight to Norm narrating his childhood from the book. Further on there's the story of sleeping beside the polar bears in the Central Park Zoo. Maybe Apatow is taking a page from Norm himself, trusting that even an invented story can tell us something true about the man.

About eleven minutes in, the film lays out the problem in a montage. Norm is a strict vegetarian who eats "chicken and beef." He asks a crowd, "Do you ever just lie for no reason at all?" He is Scottish, then Polish, then three quarters gypsy. He says he doesn't drink or smoke, and a friend of 15 years, asked about that, says, "I think he did. I'm almost certain, but I have no idea." He left school at 15, never had any schooling, and at one point mentions when he was in college. The film returns to the bit later, cutting together talk show clips in which his son is 3, then 6, then 18, and a 2020 set where Norm, around 60, calls himself "68 years young." Apatow gets his laughs from the pile-up, but the friend's answer is the only one that sounds honest.

Not long after, the film turns to Norm's jobs before fame. In an interview he lists a logging camp and a garbage truck, and I can't say he didn't make some of them up, especially with Apatow cutting in a scene from DIRTY WORK where two workers admit they lied on their resume. Then comes the narration, again from the book. "I specialized in unskilled labor, and I was good at it," Norm says, and if his job was to shovel until eight hours had passed, his body worked on its own. "It had no use for my mind, so my mind would take off to a world of imagination. And that's where stand-up comedy started." That one I believe, because I worked greens maintenance at a golf course, and a lot of my best ideas came from that job.

The film gives the sitcoms little time, and Norm does most of the dismissing himself. As he recalls it, his whole pitch was "I think I can act as good as Jerry Seinfeld." Asked about the acting, he says, "I don't like to act," and he explains that stand-ups make bad actors because the job is "you not relating to anyone." Late in the film, Norm says he's only proud of one thing, and that everything else was "an accident that came from stand-up." Apatow lets that stand as the verdict, without much consideration of whether the shows themselves were any good. I'll answer. I watched every episode of THE NORM SHOW, because how could you go wrong with Norm and a dachshund? And yet, it was at best a C+ show. I couldn't finish a single episode of A MINUTE WITH STAN HOOPER.

I hadn't realized how much of Norm's childhood was spent around old men. His father's friends came over in the evenings for "company," and Norm sat cross-legged in the corner while they told jokes. Later, as the film turns to mortality, Norm says he comes from "a long line of death." Then the narration takes over: "Death is a funny thing." In the book, that passage comes from a scene where Norm visits a dying boy in the hospital, but here it plays as his own philosophy. He says people are in "deep denial of death," and "I'm not." The film cuts straight to a man saying "not a lot of people knew" that Norm "had stomach cancer" early in his career, then fades him out mid-sentence. A 1991 Montreal Gazette article shown on screen reports that his illness began after his 1986 Just for Laughs appearance.

Norm isn't as comfortable with death as that boast suggests. In a radio interview not included in the documentary, he talks himself through an argument: when you're dead you're not alive, and when you're alive you're not dead, so "you and death will never actually cross paths." Asked whether it works, he says, "I'm not successful," and admits the fear returns "in the deep of night," when he gets up late, turns on the bathroom light and looks himself in the eye. I didn't know about the cancer, and as far as I can tell the film never returns to that first diagnosis. I wonder if a brush with mortality that early in his career affected his work afterward.

Earlier, the film includes Norm's Richard Farnsworth story, the one that led me to THE STRAIGHT STORY, about an actor who kept his cancer out of the public eye. At a 2020 show late in the film, Norm jokes that "if I die it won't be as much of a tragedy." A couple of minutes later, the film plays people reacting to the news of his death. His final illness had lasted nine years, and one of them says, "I had no idea." Jeff Ross explains, "Anything that undercuts the comedy, you don't want the audience to know." As a matter of comedy, I think Norm was right to keep it from his audience.

Then there's the special. According to a woman in the film, Norm taped it the night before a long procedure because he didn't want to leave anything on the table "in case things went south." I've watched it, the one where he sits at a laptop, and it's hard to laugh when you know how close he was to death. I'm not sure the material was great, either. Because of Covid, he never got the chance to refine the material in front of an audience, and I think it shows. It reminds me of the albums released after Tupac died. He was in the studio constantly because he thought he might die young, but with all the music he left behind, I doubt he would have considered every recording a finished song.

I think I know why I spent so much time watching Norm. John Candy died when I was a kid, and Chris Farley and Phil Hartman followed while I was in middle school. I learned early that the people I admired weren't necessarily going to be around for long. Philip Seymour Hoffman came later. I didn't grow up watching him, but as an adult I started seeing everything he made the moment it came out, and then he died on the day the Seahawks won the Super Bowl. With Norm, the habit took the form of watching whatever clips and episodes I could find online. I watched while he was still around to make more.

Near the end, Norm tells a crowd that he feels love when he does stand-up, and that "here is better than out there." What I felt watching Norm was different. I was watching alone, and he never knew I was there. He had a room full of strangers laughing with him. Apatow closes with one last ridiculous gag and The Highwaymen singing "Live Forever." It feels right for Norm. But what stays with me comes right before it. He says he'll try to say it "as unironically as possible, okay?" and then says, "I love you."

Final Verdict: 84 out of 100

Sidenote: Here's the link where you can watch the old NORM MACDONALD LIVE episodes. https://archive.org/details/Norm_Macdonald_Live

But don't watch these while driving, unless you have one of those fancy cell phone holders. Safety first.


The Truman Show (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


THE TRUMAN SHOW (1998) PG 103 Minutes Director: Peter Weir Writer: Andrew Niccol Jim Carrey, Laura Linney, Noah Emmerich CAST Jim Carrey...Truman Burbank Laura Linney...Meryl Burbank Noah Emmerich...Marlon Natascha McElhone...Sylvia Ed Harris...Christof Holland Taylor...Truman's Mother Brian Delate...Truman's Father Paul Giamatti...Control Room Director Philip Baker Hall...Network Executive Harry Shearer...Mike Michaelson
All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players;
They have their exits and their entrances;
And one man in his time plays many parts.

— William Shakespeare, AS YOU LIKE IT

Imagine growing up with a best friend, only to discover that your parents had secretly been paying him to spend time with you. Would that make your entire friendship a lie, or could something genuine have developed along the way? For Truman Burbank, the situation is several thousand times worse. Adopted as an infant by a corporation, Truman has spent his entire life surrounded by people paid to be his friends, his family, and even his wife.

The movie seems to anticipate that reaction, and its first few minutes push back against it. Before we see a single morning in Seahaven, the people around Truman are on camera describing their jobs. Christof acknowledges that Truman's world may be counterfeit, but insists there's nothing fake about Truman himself. There are no scripts or cue cards, and if it isn't always Shakespeare, it's a life. Meryl says there's no difference between her private life and her public one. The show is a lifestyle, a noble one, a truly blessed life. It's a sales pitch, obviously, and I still caught myself half-believing it. Part of the reason is that I'm not convinced a paycheck necessarily spoils a relationship. There's a crude saying that you can always learn to love a rich woman, and plenty of marriages have started on less romantic terms than that. Friendships begin at work all the time, too, and nobody asks whether the friend would have shown up without the salary. For all I know, the relationships on Truman's show were less transactional than a lot of the ones people have in real life. The difference is that everybody else on the show got to read the terms.

If any relationship in the movie can answer that question, it's Marlon's. Truman, convinced the whole world revolves around him, sits down with his oldest friend and asks whether he's losing his mind. Marlon's answer is the warmest scene in the film. He has been Truman's best friend since they were seven. They got through school cheating off each other's test papers, which he remembers as a comfort, since they were right or wrong together. He stayed up all night in Truman's tent so Truman could play North Pole, and he got pneumonia for it. Truman remembers that Marlon was out of school for a month. Truman is the closest thing he ever had to a brother, and he would gladly step in front of traffic for him. Meanwhile Christof is in his ear, feeding him the words. Christof says "walk," and Marlon, repeating the line, slightly flubs it into "step." The line about never lying to Truman goes through the same relay: Christof says it first, and Marlon echoes it with a hesitation. Seconds later he assures Truman that he isn't in on anything, because there is no "it." After two minutes of sounding sincere, he delivers the most dishonest sentence in the movie. What I can't get past is the tent. If Marlon has been in Truman's life since they were seven, someone decided that for him as a child, and he still sat up all night and got sick for his friend. The circumstances were manufactured, but the hours weren't. I made a version of this argument about Henry, the chauffeur in BLANK CHECK, who is on the payroll and is still one of the few people who seems to care what happens to Preston. The difference is that Preston knows what he's paying for. The question with Marlon isn't whether he's lying to Truman. It's whether he's lying about everything.

Meryl is where my argument runs into trouble. With Marlon, you can wonder whether the person is leaking through the job. With Meryl, it's the job leaking through the person. One of the first things we see her do is show Truman a Chef's Pal she got free at the checkout, which she pitches like an infomercial: dicer, grater, peeler, all in one. Later, when Truman studies their wedding album with a magnifying glass, he finds his bride with her fingers crossed behind her back. By the time he's cornered her, he's asking why she wants a baby with a man she can't stand, and she answers by offering him Mococoa, natural cocoa beans from Mt. Nicaragua, no artificial sweeteners. When he asks if she's part of this, she tells him he's scaring her. Soon Truman is threatening her with a kitchen utensil, asking, "Dice me, slice me or peel me?" Then she begs someone off camera to do something, and when help arrives she complains, "How can anyone expect me to carry on under these conditions? It's unprofessional!" Her fear is real, but it's difficult to find much genuine affection underneath it. The possibility of a baby makes the arrangement even uglier. Christof announces his determination to stage "TV's first on-air conception," as though bringing another human being into this world were simply a programming decision. Sylvia offers the other side of the arrangement. Christof refers to her as a former member of the cast, and when Truman first speaks to her, she says she isn't allowed to talk to him. Then she goes out with him anyway, tells him everybody is pretending, and gets written out with a story about schizophrenia and a move to Fiji. Both women were cast. One risked her job to reach him, and the other hid behind hers.

Marlon and Meryl at least get speeches. Most of Seahaven has to make do with a greeting. Christof says it takes the population of an entire country to keep the show running, and the question I kept asking is why anyone would stay for thirty years. If I were an actor who hated Truman, I don't think I could swallow it for a paycheck. Surely some of the people who've spent decades on that set have grown fond of him, even if others are simply earning a living. The town plays like a 1950s sitcom, cheerful and conformist, with neighbors so pleasant that you don't notice they're a perimeter until Truman steps out of line. A businessman and a woman with a dog force his supposedly dead father onto a bus. Traffic blocks every turn he tries. When he disappears, the townspeople organize a search, and even the Dalmatian joins in, snarling as they look for him. The commitment has a skill ceiling, though. When Truman sails off, the production wants another boat out there and discovers that its ferry crew can't sail. They're actors. Kirk, the man who played Truman's father, raises another question. Christof says Kirk was disappointed when he read the synopsis, and after he broke back onto the set, the production decided to write him into the show again, with amnesia to explain twenty-two missing years. Whether Kirk missed Truman or merely missed his job, the result was the same. The control room applauded the reunion.

Truman is the only person in the cast who doesn't know he has an audience, and Weir builds Carrey's performance around that. The rubber-faced bits survive, but they've become Truman's habits: a finger to his pulse for "Vital signs are good," a spacesuit drawn on the bathroom mirror to proclaim the planet Trumania, a panicked "Somebody help me! I'm being spontaneous!" He's a natural entertainer who doesn't know he's entertaining anyone. When the comedy stops, so does he. His last exchange with Christof, "Then who am I?", is nearly motionless. His later dramatic turns in MAN ON THE MOON and ETERNAL SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND are hard to imagine without this one. Everyone around him has the opposite job, playing a person and an employee at the same time. Noah Emmerich has the hardest assignment, since Marlon must convince Truman he's a friend while leaving us uncertain how much of the affection is sincere. Ed Harris makes Christof frightening by making him gentle. The man who says "Cue the sun" also comforts Truman like a child. Philip Baker Hall, my favorite of the bunch, plays the studio executive who finally demands that Christof cease transmission. Even his objection is a broadcast problem: "He can't die on television!" Christof's answer is "He was born on television."

Asked why Truman never came close to discovering the true nature of his world, Christof gives what amounts to the thesis of the movie: "We accept the reality of the world with which we're presented." That goes for the audience, too. The film asks us to buy into two fictional worlds. One is Seahaven, with its painted sky, its 5,000 cameras, and a studio large enough to be seen from space. The other is the society that made Seahaven possible, where a corporation can adopt a child and 1.7 billion people watch his birth. The logistics make my head spin if I think about them, so I try not to, and the movie counts on that. What interests me more is how the premise differs from THE MATRIX, which arrived less than a year later and took a similar idea somewhere colder. In THE MATRIX, the world its inhabitants experience doesn't physically exist as they perceive it. In Seahaven, everything is real, even the fake parts. The sea is real water, the sky is a real wall, and the people are real people. Truman's surroundings and relationships all exist. It's his understanding of them that has been manipulated. That puts him closer to the rest of us than any simulation story does, because most of us were handed an account of the world early on, and nobody ever walked us out to the edges to check.

The early draft shows how differently this could have gone. Andrew Niccol's Truman is thirty-four, thinning on top and soft around the middle, and the first time we see him as an adult, he's crying in his car in Queens. A few minutes later he empties a miniature bottle of Jack Daniels into his coffee. The ending is equally bleak. Truman confronts Christof on the roof of the enormous studio, screaming, "Something was real! Something had to be real!" He escapes, finds Sylvia, and has a daughter, but the show goes on without him as ZOE: "Total Record of a Human Life," with Marlon playing the new baby's father. Truman turns off the television. Weir keeps the desperation but gives us a man his own viewers call kind, maybe too kind. I think that's the right trade. A film asking whether the people around Truman could love him is more persuasive when we can understand why they might.

Surveillance gets most of the credit for this film's prescience, but the viewers are the better prediction. They aren't villains. Christof says many of them leave Truman on all night for comfort, and the movie shows them in bars and on sofas, tuning in for his first step and that stolen kiss, attached to a man who has never met them. BIG BROTHER premiered in the Netherlands the next year, and a whole economy now runs on strangers who feel they know someone they have never spoken to. Someone in the control room points out that Truman has the world's most recognizable face, and he walks into a life where everyone knows far more about him than he knows about them. I think of Britney Spears, whose fame brought extraordinary scrutiny while other people exercised control over her life. Escaping the studio won't mean escaping his audience. In the early draft, Truman gets to switch the television off himself. In the finished film, the last word goes to two security guards: "You want another slice?" "No. Let's see what else is on."

The film's last argument is about who gets to claim they know Truman. Christof asks Sylvia, on the air, whether batting her eyes at him once means she knows him. Then he tells Truman himself, "I know you better than you do," and lists the evidence: the birth, the first step, the first day of school, the lost tooth. Truman's reply is "You never had a camera in my head," and it holds up. Christof has nearly thirty years of footage and still can't predict what Truman will do when he's offered a door. The farewell that follows is the one Truman gives his neighbors on the first morning we see him: "In case I don't see you, good afternoon, good evening and good night." Except this time it's an actual goodbye. My answer to the question I opened with is that the people around him could care about him and still not have earned his trust, because he never agreed to any of it. Thirty years is a long time to know someone. It might not be long enough to know them completely.

Final Verdict: 91 out of 100


Equilibrium (Retro)

by Edward Dunn


EQUILIBRIUM (2002) R 107 Minutes Director: Kurt Wimmer Writer: Kurt Wimmer Christian Bale, Emily Watson, Taye Diggs CAST Christian Bale...John Preston Emily Watson...Mary O'Brien Taye Diggs...Brandt Angus Macfadyen...DuPont Sean Bean...Partridge William Fichtner...Jurgen
Too long a sacrifice / Can make a stone of the heart.

— W. B. Yeats, "Easter, 1916"

I had been an adult for less than six months when I first saw EQUILIBRIUM, and apparently one of the first things I wanted to do with my newfound independence was skip community college and drive several towns away to see a movie. I had spotted an ad for it in the Seattle Weekly, but its limited release meant the nearest showing was at the Parkway Plaza theater in Tukwila. I didn't bother with MapQuest — just a crude map from the paper, the theater's address, and the freeway signs. It poured rain the entire way, and getting there and back turned into considerably more of an ordeal than I had anticipated. But there was something thrilling about it too. I was eighteen, nobody needed to give me permission, and if I wanted to spend an afternoon hunting down some strange dystopian Christian Bale movie in Tukwila, I could.

Equilibrium (2002) poster captioned "Generic sci-fi thriller?"

Even at eighteen, I could tell where EQUILIBRIUM had been shopping. Prozium is the soma of BRAVE NEW WORLD by another name, Father is Big Brother with a bigger screen, and the Clerics burn paintings and records the way the firemen of FAHRENHEIT 451 burn books, right down to the enforcer who gets undone by the thing he's paid to destroy. It even drifts into PLEASANTVILLE territory, another immaculate world where feeling has been flattened out and the first glimpse of what's been drained away hits like a revelation. Aside from the special effects, this is almost a movie that teleported in from the 1970s. The film doesn't hide any of it. Wimmer's own production notes name Huxley, Orwell and Bradbury as inspirations. Taye Diggs even says he read two of them to prepare for Brandt. That candor is rare. Most art is built from earlier art, and most artists work hard to hide the receipts. It didn't bother me then, because the ideas were still worth exploring, and it doesn't bother me now. Besides, none of its ancestors ever got around to a martial art built around two pistols.

Libria also has a staffing problem that anyone who has watched a cop show could have predicted. The Clerics spend their days around exactly what the state wants gone, which is the kind of setup that can turn vice cops into users. Partridge is the proof. When Preston asks why he didn't leave a book for the evidentiary team, he says they miss things sometimes and he'd rather get it done properly himself, with Yeats in his pocket. Later Brandt asks Preston the same question about a Beethoven record and gets nearly the same answer. Even Brandt, the loyal one, has a version of the problem. If they keep burning all this contraband, he muses, eventually there won't be anything left to burn, and what will there be for men like them? That's a man with a stake in the crime he exists to eliminate. It makes sense that a revolution would begin with one of these guys rather than an ordinary citizen. They're the only people in the city who get to handle the forbidden material. You would think the architect of such a society would compartmentalize things a bit more. Partridge walks through the gate into the nether every night for two weeks and the guard assumes it's enforcement-related. His evidence log goes empty for weeks and nobody notices until Preston asks. A regime that bans mirror frames leaves its most dangerous employees on the honor system.

The deeper flaw is that Prozium never works the way the speeches say it does. The film keeps showing a society that seems to have removed tenderness, empathy, grief, and aesthetic pleasure while leaving plenty of other feelings intact. Brandt is proud and ambitious and laughs out loud when his trap closes. DuPont is vain, short-tempered, and visibly rattled once Preston starts winning. When Brandt tells Preston that obedience to Father is a matter of faith, he's describing a feeling with better PR. Father himself is the biggest tell. He died years ago, and the Council keeps his face on the screens because obedience needs someone to obey. Even the Prestons are leaking. Robbie snaps at Lisa for playing with her cereal, which reads as a stray bit of behavior until he hands his father the dose and says he and his sister quit taking it after their mother died. That makes the title more interesting than I first gave it credit for. Libria's idea of equilibrium is a flatline. Jurgen comes closer to a definition: emotion has a price, and without restraint it's chaos, but the answer is control, not removal. Partridge says the price of feeling is one he'd pay gladly, and near the end, when DuPont asks Preston whether it's worth it, Preston says the same thing back. This time it sounds like a man who has found his balance.

Preston's abilities are the film's other contradiction. According to the production notes, Bale took an eight-week Judo course and trained with stunt coordinator Jim Vickers in Japanese fighting arts and the handling of multiple guns, and Wimmer says almost all of the fight scenes were shot in a single take. It shows. The choreography is clear and fast, and some of it wouldn't look out of place in JOHN WICK (2014). DuPont's explanation of Gun Kata is another matter. He throws out a 120% gain in firing efficiency and a 63% gain in lethal proficiency, numbers that sound precise and explain nothing. The better question is why a government that blames violence on emotion would build its deadliest man. It's the old Rambo problem: institutions are comfortable manufacturing violence until it stops obeying orders. The film's answer is to give Preston something he can't shoot. When the Clerics raid a kennel in the nether, he rescues one dog with a thin excuse about disease testing, and later the dog is why he ends up killing a patrol of his own side. That scene is where the two halves of Preston finally meet: the machine's efficiency gets spent on something small and helpless, with no speech about feeling required. Apparently I've stumbled into another movie where a dog matters. This one appears in a handful of scenes, which is the right ratio for a film that isn't about the dog, and it returns at the end with Lisa.

The cast has to do a lot with very little face, and most of them manage it. Bale's job is to change visibly while looking like he hasn't, and the production notes say he and Wimmer worked to avoid winking at the audience. Some of his best work is in his hands. Preston peels off a glove to feel a handrail, then again to find a hidden cache, and both read louder than most shouting. Emily Watson, who had already appeared opposite Bale in METROLAND, plays Mary with her usual seriousness, plus an edge of something eerie. It keeps her from being only the woman who teaches him to feel. Taye Diggs and Angus Macfadyen have the opposite assignment, playing men who are supposed to feel nothing and visibly feel plenty. The press kit says Wimmer cast Diggs for his smile, a smart choice in a world where smiling is suspect. Macfadyen's DuPont is a showman, and when it's time to threaten Preston he borrows Partridge's Yeats. Sean Bean and William Fichtner each get the scene where someone explains what Libria costs, and each delivers it as if the bill has already come due. Most of these characters are more functional than developed, but the cast sells the function.

The premise has aged in odd directions. Wimmer has said he wanted a parallel world, not a gadget future, and the technology is modest enough now to be charming. The one thing the movie got exactly right about the future is the bad video-conference background. That modesty also leaves the regime looking fragile. A society built around one drug stores it in glass ampoules, and Preston's awakening begins when one shatters at his sink. The resistance's plan is fragile in the same way: bomb the clinics and factories, and if the supply stops for even a day, human nature will handle the rest. That's a plan without a day after. Robbie asking whether he should report another boy for crying lands differently in an age when everyone carries a report button, and Preston's flat "Unquestionably" is the right answer for the world he lives in. Dystopias are easier to enjoy when the future they describe is far away, and this one has moved closer.

The early draft shows what Wimmer changed his mind about. In it, Preston reaches Mary before the incinerator, and they get a goodbye: she makes him promise her death won't be for nothing, steps into the chamber, and is gone in a flash. Then, near the end, she turns up alive in a hidden room behind a mirror, and the script closes on the two of them kissing as the drug factories explode. The finished film is harsher. Preston arrives too late, watches the doors close on her, and ends with her ribbon instead of her. That gives the victory a cost the draft never charged. The film also makes better use of Brandt. In the draft he's dragged off to be burned and never comes back, and the line about asking a Cleric for his gun comes from an unseen voice. In the film he returns, smiling, as the trap whose job was to make Preston feel safe. Both changes follow the same instinct. A movie that keeps talking about the price of feeling should make someone pay it.

EQUILIBRIUM has never been easy to find. Dimension Films opened it in 301 theaters, and it took in about $1.2 million at the American box office against a $20 million budget. Wimmer later said the studio didn't know how to market a film with both action and ideas. The DVD was the next hurdle, since the Blockbuster copy was always gone. This time it was streaming: it turned up on Paramount+ long enough for me to watch it once, then disappeared, and I had to rent it elsewhere. Watching at home, on a television, I was seeing a smaller movie. Part of what had stuck with me was the trip itself: the rain, the freeway signs and the paper map. The rest was scale. The production notes say Libria's architecture was designed to make the individual feel small. On a theater screen, it did. On my television, it looked like a pretty good screensaver. I remembered EQUILIBRIUM as a bigger movie than it really is, but the first time I saw it, I was eighteen and it literally was.

Final Verdict: 74 out of 100

Sidenote: Dimension Films was a Miramax label at the time (yes, that Miramax), and Miramax itself was owned by Disney.


Heart of the Beast

by Edward Dunn


HEART OF THE BEAST (2026) PG-13 101 Minutes Director: David Ayer Writer: Cameron Alexander Brad Pitt, J.K. Simmons, Anna Lambe CAST Brad Pitt...James Belmont J.K. Simmons...Watkins Anna Lambe...Amber Uber...Odin
Life's just better with a dog.

— Brad Pitt
Heart of the Beast (2026)

After watching ONCE UPON A TIME IN HOLLYWOOD, one lesson can be gleaned: we need more movies with Brad Pitt and a dog. He clearly has chemistry with animals. Maybe we had to wait until he was secure enough in his career to spend most of a movie wandering through the wilderness with a German shepherd. And it's good to know he's not faking the funk — Pitt has been a dog owner for decades, and by all accounts, the affection on screen isn't an act.

The ordinary bond between a man and a dog is profound enough on its own. But James and Odin are old war buddies, and that's a connection that's harder to fathom. I think of a 1999 Discovery Channel documentary, WAR DOGS: AMERICA'S FORGOTTEN HEROES, about Vietnam-era handlers forced to leave their dogs behind at the end of deployment, when military dogs were still treated as equipment and many never came home. The men interviewed were gruff and weathered, and one after another they cried on camera over dogs they'd lost. HEART OF THE BEAST is built on that same grief: two creatures who went to war together and came home changed, with only each other left to prove any of it happened.

Pitt plays James Belmont, a retired Special Forces soldier whose plane goes down in the Alaskan backcountry with his combat dog, Odin, aboard. There's little dialogue, so the story is told through what you see, and almost anything I describe would ruin it. That makes this review more about my reaction than the plot. Every review is about feelings, but this one admits it. One spoiler, and the first scene beats me to it: the dog lives. I knew that. I had a pretty good idea what trials were coming. None of that protected me from the movie. The interesting question isn't really what happens next. It's why something this simple, and this easy to anticipate, hit me the way it did.

For a movie about two war veterans, one of them a dog, it barely explains the war. What backstory there is arrives over a beer with Watkins, a former gold miner played by J.K. Simmons. He pitches his tent next to James's and hopes that's all right, then takes a second beer from the cooler and hopes that's all right too. Simmons has a type I'm starting to notice: confident characters with a bit of hesitancy underneath. It works here. When Watkins asks about the titanium in Odin's mouth, James gives a flat, matter-of-fact explanation, then drops the darkest part like it's nothing. The flashbacks do the opposite. They're so chaotic that you never find your bearings or follow the fighting. All you really understand is that James and his dog went through hell together, which turns out to be plenty.

When James talks, it's mostly to Odin. He introduces Odin like a prizefighter, the king of all three-legged creatures, and puts double portions to a vote. When a nightmare rattles Odin, the reassurance is in the plural: "We're not there anymore." Odin holds up his end, and the two of them keep saving each other. Pitt's ease with the dog has preparation behind it: David Ayer says Pitt arrived in New Zealand early, worked with the dogs, learned some of the handling himself, and got to know Uber, his primary canine co-star. I remember watching MEGAN LEAVEY (2017), about a Marine and her bomb-sniffing dog, and thinking there wasn't enough dog. Nobody will have that complaint here.

What got me was a blanket. At one point the movie gives Odin a nylon Army camo blanket. I once laid the same kind over my own dog while she slept, sick with an illness we couldn't identify and weren't sure she'd get over. She did, and she slept with that blanket every day afterward. The movie knew nothing about that, and it didn't need to. It only had to put the blanket in the frame and let me do the rest.

Knowing the dog lives only protects you from the plot. The blanket carried the part where I didn't know if my own dog would pull through, and no opening scene can spoil that. Ayer has said his biggest battle was embracing how simple the story is. I'm glad he won it. I went in expecting a mom movie, and I probably would have been perfectly satisfied with one. They didn't have to make it this good. The dog lives, and I'm still not over it.

Final Verdict: 92 out of 100

Sidenote:

Dogsmoke